emjay wrote:It's silly to try to compare fighters based on what they did against a common opponent because styles make fights and ... IT'S A FIGHT and anything can happen. Matt Serra beat GSP, remember?
Bad comparison. Comparing Rashad and Lyoto based on the Tito fight is reasonably accurate because they both had to fight the same guy back to back. How they preformed against Tito gives a good idea as to how they would preform against each other. Lyoto did MUCH better than Rashad in his fight with Ortiz. Simple (at least for most of us). Sure, anything can happen in a fight, but I can pull up the records of both if you'd like and you'll find that Lyoto's undefeated run is far more impressive. He has no split decisions or close fights. Rashad has 4 split/majority decisions and a draw. Use your head.
emjay wrote:I saw both fights. With all of the "just becauses" about Tito grabbing the fence, what about the "what if" Tito didn't grab the fence and Rashad got him down? There's a reason Tito grabbed the fence ... so not to go down

The entire fight is different (in whose favor? who knows) if Tito doesn't grab the fence.
Again, bad logic. Yes, Titio grabbed the fence to keep from going down. He was also winning the fight. The point Tito lost from the fence grab is what allowed Rashad to continue his undefeated streak. Rashad proved he couldn't finish Tito on the ground, so I doubt it would have mattered at all even if he had gotten that take down.
emjay wrote:By your logic, Rashad Evans has more power in his right hand than Rampage. They both caught Chuck with a right, but Evans put Chuck completely to sleep while Rampage's shot only knocked Chuck down.

One, that doesn't make any sense, because I'm comparing the fight performance of two guys who fought the same opponent back to back. Its not a comparison of the power or even just the end result.
Two, I'll try to make this easy for you: They both caught Chuck with a right hook. The placement of the hook was very different though. Rampage's shot was very wide and barely clipped Chuck. Rashad's, on the other hand, was close in and caught Chuck flush, full on in the side of the jaw while Chuck's head was moving forward. Whether or not Rashad can punch harder is not the point. His punch landed better and the momentum was far greater. The "power of his right arm" was moot at that point. If Rampage had caught Chuch that full on, Chuck would...actually, just watch Rampage/Wanderlei III to get an idea
emjay wrote:No. Watch his face before he drops to his knees, he couldn't believe the fight was a draw. Had nothing to do with whether he survived Tito Ortiz or not.
That doesn't make any fucking sense at all.
"He couldn't believe it was a draw. It had nothing to do with him surviving."
Holy fucking contradiction. Do you even read what you post?
Rashad thanked god and dropped to his knees because
he thought he had lost the fight. Thats why he was so surprised and happy that it was a draw. Jesus.